Monday, October 27, 2014

Juvenal and the U.S.

1.     School System-“I have never examined the entrails of a frog.”
a.     Just as in the United States, Juvenal mocks Rome’s educational system. He dramatically hyperbolizes Rome’s situation by saying that he, as a student, never even studied the anatomy of an animal. Clearly, Juvenal is demonstrating his disgust at the school system.
2.     Health Care System-“Here in Rome the son of free-born parents has to give the wall to some rich man's slave; for that other will give as much as the whole pay of a legionary tribune to enjoy the chance favours of a Calvina[17] or a Catiena,[17] while you, when the face of some gay-decked harlot takes your fancy, scarce venture to hand Chione down from her lofty chair.”
a.     In the United States today, many rich bemoan how their taxes go to pay for the poor man’s health care. Likewise, Juvenal criticizes how “the son of free-born parents has to give the wall to some rich man’s slave.” A true citizen has to help someone who has a lower-income than him and that, in Juvenal’s view, should not be tolerated.
3.     Nutritional Problems-“It is no easy matter, anywhere, for a man to rise when poverty stands in the way of his merits: but nowhere is the effort harder than in Rome, where you must pay a big rent for a wretched lodging, a big sum to fill the bellies of your slaves, and buy a frugal dinner for yourself.”
a.     Juvenal says that he intends to leave Rome because he can only “buy a frugal dinner for” himself here. Likewise, many in the United States can only afford cheap dollar-menu items with no nutritional value.
4.     Mental Health: “What else can you do when attacked by a madman stronger than yourself?”
a.     Juvenal questions what would happen if a “madman” came at you. By using this term, “madman,” Juvenal demonstrates how he also does not understand mental illnesses. He frivolously uses the term “madman” to describe a dangerous man and yet, he does not know the mental health of that person. Likewise, not all mentally ill persons are dangerous. Thus, just as in the United States, Juvenal demonstrates an ignorance regarding mental illness.
5.     Literary Loss-"What can I do at Rome? I cannot lie; if a book is bad, I cannot praise it, and beg for a copy.”

a.     Juvenal recognizes that there are poor quality books in Rome. While the Romans certainly did not suffer from using clipped sentences on Facebook, they still struggled, apparently, to create noteworthy literary texts.

3 comments:

  1. It's very interesting how Juvenal wrote about a lot of things that are similar today in the U.S. and what Rome was. I like that you pointed out how people can only afford cheap meals with no nutritional values.

    ReplyDelete
  2. So interesting!!! I love reading your comments. It is also interesting to see how literacy can be such a stumbling block in society.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with your assessment about the ignorance surrounding me mental illness....we tend to assume anyone that does something really bad is mentally ill, which creates a false sense of dangerousness surrounding mental illness...in actuality, the number of people who are dangerous due to mental illness is very, very slim....and it is likely a correlation, not causal. However, this bias can cause serious damage to innocent people that also suffer from mental illness, even costing them their jobs . So grateful for your insight and awareness of this

    ReplyDelete